Insights · AI visibility

SEO versus AI visibility: what changes for local businesses

How AI search differs from ranked Google results, what a Costa del Sol business should keep, stop and start doing, and where to spend your effort now.

SEO gets your pages into Google’s list of links. AI visibility gets your business named in the answer itself, in ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google’s AI Overviews. The second builds on the first, so you don’t throw your SEO away. But it asks a different question, it is measured differently, and it leans more on what other people say about you.

What is the difference in one line?

SEO asks: does my page rank in Google’s list of links?

AI visibility asks: when someone asks an AI who to use, does it name my business?

A page can rank on Google and still be absent from the AI answer. The reverse happens too.

How does each one reward you?

In traditional SEO, Google crawls the web, builds an index and ranks pages. When someone searches “estate agent Marbella”, Google returns an ordered list of links. Your reward is a higher position. The unit of success is a click: the customer clicks through to your site and does the rest.

In AI search, the engine still reads the web, but it doesn’t return a list. It writes an answer. Ask “who is the best estate agent in Marbella for British buyers?” and ChatGPT writes a paragraph naming two or three agencies and saying why.

The unit of success is now a mention. The customer may never visit your website, because the answer gave them enough to act on. They message the named agency on WhatsApp, ask a follow-up question, or remember the name for later. You are no longer optimising for a position in a list. You are optimising for inclusion in a sentence.

How does AI pick its sources?

This is the part most SEO guides skip. When you ask ChatGPT a question, it doesn’t read the whole internet in real time. It runs a retrieval step first: it searches the web, fetches a handful of pages it thinks are relevant, and reads only those. Then it writes its answer from what it read.

That retrieval step behaves a bit like Google Search, with some differences. It tends to favour pages that answer the question directly, in plain language, with specific facts. It tends to favour independent sources over self-promotion. And for questions where recency matters, it prefers recent content.

So the pages that rank well in Google are not always the pages AI retrieves. A forum thread with a direct answer can beat your polished homepage. A review site can be read ahead of your own service page. For more on this, see how AI cites sources.

How does AI write the answer?

Once the model has read its sources, it condenses them into a few sentences. It tends to name businesses that several sources agree on, described in similar terms. It hedges when sources conflict. And it favours businesses it can describe specifically: “the estate agent for Scandinavian buyers in Mijas” is easier to repeat than “a leading real estate agency”.

That is why consistency matters so much. If your business is described one way on your website, another on Google and a third on a directory, the model has to reconcile conflicting information, and it becomes less confident naming you. If every source says the same thing, it can say it too.

What stays the same?

AI engines read the web. ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity all search it, and Google’s AI Overviews are built on top of Google Search. So the basics of good SEO still help both:

  • A fast, mobile-friendly site that search engines can crawl.
  • Clear pages that answer real questions.
  • A Google Business Profile that is complete and accurate.
  • Genuine reviews from real customers.
  • Links and mentions from trusted, relevant sites.

If your SEO foundations are broken, fix them first.

What changes?

Position versus mention. SEO rewards a high position in a list. AI search rewards a mention in a sentence, with an accurate one-line description.

Your site versus the web. SEO is mostly about your own website. AI search weighs third-party sources heavily: reviews, directories, press, forums and guides. Your own site still matters, but the model wants corroboration. What your reviews say matters more than it used to.

Rankings reports versus answer tracking. A monthly report of Google positions says nothing about whether ChatGPT recommends you. You have to track AI answers directly, question by question, across engines.

Keep, stop, start

Keep: a healthy, fast site; useful content; a well-maintained Google Business Profile; genuine reviews.

Stop: thin “SEO pages” stuffed with town names; chasing low-quality links; judging success only on Google rankings.

Start: asking AI engines your buyers’ questions every month; writing down who gets named and why; earning mentions in the sources those answers cite; describing your business the same way everywhere.

Where to begin

Pick ten questions your best customers would ask, in their language. Put them to ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity. If you’re named, great. If a competitor is named instead, that’s your to-do list. Our guide on how to check what ChatGPT says about your business walks through it step by step, and how to get your business recommended by ChatGPT covers what to fix.

Or let us do it for you. Our free AI visibility check tests ten questions across three engines, compares you with three competitors and lands in your inbox within five working days.

See what ChatGPT says about you today

Ten real buyer questions. Three AI engines. You and three competitors. A short report in your inbox within five working days, free.

Get your free AI visibility check